SALARYMAXReads

Basics ・ 6 min

Do employee referrals stay longer? US company data

In US company records, referred applicants were more likely to be hired and less likely to quit. Starting pay was 2.1% higher, but the gap faded in about three years.

Do employee referrals stay longer? US company data — 2.1%: Starting-pay gap for referred hires (US, observational study)

The evidence behind this article

  • Adjusted observational2

Based on observational data. It shows that two things go together, not that one causes the other.

2 sources・Countries studied: United States

How to read the kinds of evidence →

What to do with this

If you apply through a referral, ask who does well in the job and who struggles, and compare where you might be in three years, not just the starting pay.

What is different about people who join a company because a current employee recommended them? In US company records, referred applicants were more likely to be hired and less likely to leave. Their pay was slightly higher at the start, and the gap disappeared within a few years.

Key points

  • In personnel data from nine large US firms in call centers, trucking and high-tech (Burks and colleagues, 2015), workers hired through employee referrals were less likely to quit and earned slightly higher wages. Their measured skills and most performance measures were about the same as other hires.
  • In 2000–2011 hiring records from one US financial services company (Brown and colleagues, 2016), referred hires started on 2.1% higher pay, but the gap was gone after about three years. They were about 85% as likely to leave as non-referred hires.
  • Both are observational studies that compare company records with statistical controls, not experiments in which referrals were assigned by lottery. No Japanese study on the retention or pay of referred hires was found.

What did referred workers look like in nine large firms?

Stephen Burks and his co-authors used personnel data from nine large firms in three industries: call centers, long-distance trucking, and high-tech/IT. The workers were mostly in the United States. The researchers combined hiring records, performance data and surveys to compare referred and non-referred workers.

Referred applicants were more likely to be hired and more likely to accept an offer. Yet their measured skills were about the same, and on most everyday performance measures they did no better. The differences showed up in rare but important events: referred truck drivers had fewer accidents, and referred high-tech workers produced more patents.

The biggest difference was staying power. In the 2013 working-paper version of the study, referred workers were 10–30% less likely to quit. Their wages were only slightly higher. In call centers and trucking, where profit per worker could be calculated, referred workers were more profitable, and the gap came from lower turnover and lower recruiting costs.

The authors’ reading is that referrals mainly help firms find people who fit the specific job. People also tend to refer others like themselves, and the profit gap was driven by referrals from high-performing employees.

How did pay and tenure change after a referral at one financial firm?

Meta Brown, Elizabeth Setren and Giorgio Topa studied one US financial services company with 2,000 to 5,000 employees. They used records on everyone hired from 2000 to April 2011 and applicants from 2006 to 2010. The analysis covered 1,774 employees, 29% of whom had been referred by a current employee.

Referred candidates made up only 6% of applicants but 29% of hires. Compared with applicants from online job boards, they were 7.3 percentage points more likely to be interviewed, and among those interviewed, 14.0 percentage points more likely to receive an offer.

Holding other factors equal, referred hires started on 2.1% higher pay, or more than $1,300. That advantage shrank each year, and after about three years of tenure their pay was roughly the same as everyone else’s. Referred workers were about 85% as likely to leave the company, and there was no difference in promotion rates. These figures come from the 2013 revised report that preceded the journal version.

How far can referral research take us, and does it apply to Japan?

This evidence supports one claim: at these US companies, referred hires tended to stay longer and to start on slightly higher pay. Both studies are observational. Nobody decided by lottery who would be referred. People who come in through a referral may simply have known more about the job before they started.

The settings are also narrow: nine large firms in three industries, and one financial services company. We found no Japanese study on how referred hires fare in retention or pay. Hiring routes and pay systems differ in Japan, so the numbers should not be carried over directly. The pay gap was also small and faded within a few years.

A small step for today

The most reasonable lesson from this research is that the value of a referral seems to lie in knowing, before you join, whether the job suits you.

  • When you apply through someone you know, ask them what kind of person does well in the role and who tends to struggle. On that day, tick “Prepared for a negotiation” and write down what you heard.
  • Do not decide on starting pay alone. The referral pay gap disappeared in about three years, so also compare what your work might look like by then.
  • Use “Wrote one line on today’s progress” to keep a record of your work. It gives you concrete material when you refer someone or ask to be referred.

FAQ

Will I get a higher salary if I join through a referral?

In the US financial services study, referred hires started on 2.1% higher pay, but the gap disappeared after about three years. In the nine-firm study the wage difference was only slight. Because these are observational studies, they do not show that the referral itself raised anyone’s pay.

Are referred employees really less likely to quit?

In both US studies, referred workers tended to leave less often. At the financial firm they were about 85% as likely to leave, and the nine-firm working paper put their quit rate 10–30% lower. People who come through referrals may also have fit the job better from the start.

Do referral hires stay longer in Japan too?

We found no Japanese study on the retention or pay of people hired through employee referrals. Results from large US companies may not apply directly to Japanese firms. The research describes average tendencies, not a prediction for any one person.

Sources

  • [X-burks-2015] Burks, Cowgill, Hoffman & Housman (2015) The Value of Hiring through Employee Referrals. The Quarterly Journal of Economics.
  • [X-brown-setren-topa-2016] Brown, Setren & Topa (2016) Do Informal Referrals Lead to Better Matches? Evidence from a Firm’s Employee Referral System. Journal of Labor Economics.

Studies describe average tendencies. This article is not a promise that a habit will lift your income, and it is not medical or investment advice. About these articles ・ Search & sources

Updated:

← All articles