Practice ・ 6 min
Does temptation bundling help you keep exercising?
In a US trial, gym-only audiobooks raised visits by 51% in week one, but the effect faded. A 6,792-person follow-up found a 10–14% higher chance of a weekly workout.

The evidence behind this article
- Randomised trial2
Includes studies built to test cause and effect (randomised trials or natural experiments).
2 sources・Countries studied: United States
How to read the kinds of evidence →What to do with this
Pick one audiobook or podcast you only listen to while exercising, and decide not to play it at any other time. Log the days you move.
If you save something you enjoy for the time you spend exercising, will you exercise more? In a US experiment, letting people listen to gripping audiobooks only at the gym increased gym visits. The effect shrank over time, though, and a much larger follow-up found a benefit that lasted but was smaller.
Key points
- In a randomised trial of 226 people at a US university (Milkman and colleagues, 2014), the group that could listen to their chosen audio novels only at the gym visited 51% more often than the control group in the first week. The effect shrank week by week, especially after a university holiday.
- In the same study, 61% of participants chose to pay, after the study ended, for access to audiobooks they could hear only at the gym. Many people actively wanted a way to tie a pleasure to their workouts.
- In a follow-up with 6,792 people by a US research team (Kirgios and colleagues, 2020), the group given an audiobook and encouraged to bundle was 10–14% more likely to work out in a given week, with a difference lasting up to 17 weeks after the program. Compared with simply getting an audiobook, the added benefit of the encouragement was modest.
How did gym visits change when audiobooks were gym-only?
“Temptation bundling” means pairing something instantly enjoyable that you want to do with something that pays off later that you should do. Katherine Milkman and colleagues introduced the idea in a 2014 paper and tested it in the field.
The participants were 226 students, faculty and staff at a large university in the northeastern US. They were recruited in September 2011, and their gym visits were counted from entry records for about nine weeks. A lottery split them into three groups:
- Full bundling (75 people): an iPod loaded with four audio novels of their choice, which they could use only at the gym.
- Intermediate (75 people): the audio novels on their own device, with encouragement to listen only at the gym.
- Control (76 people): a $25 bookstore gift card of similar value.
In the first week, the full bundling group made 0.48 more gym visits than the control group, a 51% increase. The intermediate group went 29% more often, but that difference was statistically weak. Over the seven weeks before the university’s Thanksgiving break, the average total was 7.8 visits for full bundling, 6.5 for intermediate and 6.1 for control.
Did the effect last, and what did the 6,792-person follow-up find?
The effect shrank week by week. It weakened especially after the Thanksgiving break, when the gym was closed. Once the routine was broken, the bundle alone did not easily restart it. The researchers also report that the busiest participants benefited the most.
After the study, 61% of participants chose to pay for gym-only access to audiobooks. Many people, it seems, did not want to rely on willpower alone and preferred to tie the pleasure to the workout.
Kirgios and colleagues (2020) later tested the same idea at scale. They split 6,792 participants in a four-week exercise program into three groups: an audiobook plus encouragement to listen only while working out, an audiobook alone, or neither. The encouraged group was 10–14% more likely to work out in a given week and made 10–12% more weekly workouts, with differences lasting up to 17 weeks after the program ended.
Compared with getting an audiobook alone, though, the extra benefit of the encouragement was modest. The authors suggest that simply receiving an audiobook from an exercise program already hints that you should listen while working out.
How far does this evidence go on temptation bundling?
Both studies were randomised experiments, so we can say that pairing exercise with a pleasure increased exercise. But the first study involved 226 people at one US university over about nine weeks, and its large early effect faded within weeks. The difference that remained in the larger follow-up was around 10%, much smaller than the first 51%.
The participants were in the US, and we did not find any Japanese study. Neither study looked at work or income. What we can say is that pairing exercise with something you enjoy tends to raise how often you exercise a little.
A small step for today
- Choose one audiobook or podcast that you only listen to while exercising. The key is not to play it at other times.
- On days you walk or move while listening, log “Moved for 5+ minutes” or “Walked 8,000+ steps.”
- If a holiday or a trip breaks the routine, move for just five minutes so you can hear the next chapter. In the experiment, the effect weakened after a break.
FAQ
What is temptation bundling?
It is a way of pairing something instantly enjoyable that you want to do with something that pays off later that you should do. In a US experiment, letting people listen to their chosen audio novels only at the gym increased gym visits.
Does pairing exercise with something you enjoy help you keep going?
In an experiment with 6,792 people run by a US research team, the group encouraged to bundle was 10–14% more likely to work out in a given week, and the difference lasted up to 17 weeks after the program. In the first experiment, though, the effect shrank within weeks.
Does it have to be an audiobook?
The experiments tested audio novels and audiobooks. Whether other pleasures work the same way has not been tested, but the idea is the same: choose something you only enjoy while you exercise.
Sources
- [X-milkman-minson-volpp-2014] Milkman, Minson & Volpp (2014) Holding the Hunger Games Hostage at the Gym: An Evaluation of Temptation Bundling. Management Science.
- [X-kirgios-2020] Kirgios et al. (2020) Teaching temptation bundling to boost exercise: A field experiment. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes.
Studies describe average tendencies. This article is not a promise that a habit will lift your income, and it is not medical or investment advice. About these articles ・ Search & sources
Updated:
← All articles