Practice ・ 7 min
Do job training programmes work? 200+ studies and US trials
A review of 200+ evaluations found training effects on jobs are small at first and grow after two years. In US randomised trials, sector training raised earnings 12–34%.

The evidence behind this article
- Randomised trial1
- Research synthesis2
- Adjusted observational1
Includes studies built to test cause and effect (randomised trials or natural experiments).
4 sources・Countries studied: United States, Japan, Several countries
How to read the kinds of evidence →What to do with this
When choosing a training course, check whether it leads to jobs employers in your area are hiring for and whether it offers help finding work afterwards.
Does job training help people find work and earn more after a layoff or a career change? A review of more than 200 evaluations from around the world found that training effects tend to be small right after a programme ends and larger two to three years later. In US randomised trials, training focused on sectors with strong hiring demand raised participants’ earnings by 12–34%.
Key points
- Card, Kluve and Weber (2018) pooled 857 estimates from 207 studies in a meta-analysis (a study that combines many studies) and concluded that job programmes have small average effects within a year of finishing, but larger effects two to three years later. Programs that build skills showed larger effects over time.
- Katz and colleagues (2022) reviewed four US randomised trials of sector-focused training, in which programmes work with local employers to train low-wage workers for in-demand fields. Earnings rose 12–34% after training, and the gains lasted. They came not only from more people working but from people moving into higher-paying jobs.
- In Japan, Hara (2022) used a large government survey and found that unemployed people who took public job training were 15.4 percentage points (men) and 17.4 points (women) more likely to be working afterwards than similar people who did not. Women also saw gains in income and in the chance of regular employment.
When do the effects of job training show up across 200+ studies?
David Card, Jochen Kluve and Andrea Weber (2018) collected evaluations of active labour market programmes, which include job training, job search assistance and wage subsidies for the unemployed. Their sample covered 207 studies and 857 estimates.
In the working-paper figures, effects on the probability of employment were centred around 1 to 3 percentage points within a year of finishing, 3 to 5 points after one to two years, and 5 to 12 points after more than two years.
The pattern differed by type. Job search assistance had similar effects in the short and long run, while training had larger effects from the second year on. Effects were larger for women and for people who had been unemployed for a long time, and smaller for older workers and young people. Average effects from randomised trials were not very different from those of other methods.
How much did sector-focused training raise earnings?
Lawrence Katz, Jonathan Roth, Richard Hendra and Kelsey Schaberg (2022) reviewed four US randomised trials of sector-focused training. Applicants who passed an initial screening were assigned by lottery either to get access to the programme or not. Participants were mainly low-income adults and young adults.
These programmes partner with local employers to pick well-paid, in-demand occupations, such as IT, health care and manufacturing. They combine upfront screening, training in job skills and workplace soft skills, job placement and ongoing support. Earnings rose 12–34% after training, and the gains persisted in trials with longer follow-up.
One of them, WorkAdvance, recruited participants from 2011 to 2013 through four providers in New York City, Tulsa in Oklahoma, and northeast Ohio. Two years after random assignment, the share of people working in the targeted sectors was more than twice as high in the programme group as in the control group. Earnings rose not only because more people worked but because they found jobs in higher-paying industries and occupations.
How far does job training research apply to Japan?
What this evidence supports is twofold: on average, training effects on employment are small at first and tend to grow over time, and in US lottery-based trials, sector-focused training raised earnings. But sector programmes screen applicants first, and the trials were run among people who passed that screen. The same effect cannot be assumed for everyone.
For Japan, Hara herself has described her 2022 paper, in a government meeting presentation, as the first peer-reviewed study of the effects of training for the unemployed in Japan. The meta-analysis above draws on studies from 47 countries but includes none from Japan. Hara pooled data from the 2007, 2012 and 2017 rounds of Japan’s Employment Status Survey and compared trainees with statistically similar non-trainees (propensity score matching). Because this is not an experiment, unseen differences between the groups may remain, and the results cover only a short period after training. Hara calls the study just a first step for Japan.
A small step for today
The research supports choosing training by where it leads, and expecting that benefits may take time to appear.
- Check job postings to see whether the course leads to occupations that employers near you are hiring for. In the US, training focused on in-demand fields raised earnings.
- Find out whether the programme helps with job placement and support afterwards. Use “Set when and where to do tomorrow’s key task” to set a day to visit an information session or office.
- While you train, keep up “Studied for 30 minutes” and keep a record even if results are slow. Effects tended to grow two to three years later.
FAQ
Does job training make it easier to find a job?
On average, it tends to raise the chance of employment, but the size depends on the type of programme and the timing. In a review of over 200 studies, effects were small right after training and larger after two years. In Japan, trainees were also more likely to be working than similar non-trainees.
Will job training raise my pay?
It depends on the programme. In US randomised trials, programmes that focused on in-demand fields and also helped with job placement raised earnings by 12–34%. A major reason was that people moved into higher-paying jobs.
Does public job training in Japan work?
A study using Japanese government survey data found that unemployed people who took public training were 15.4 percentage points (men) and 17.4 points (women) more likely to be working than similar people who did not. It is an observational analysis, not an experiment, and covers a short period.
Sources
- [X-card-kluve-weber-2018] Card, Kluve & Weber (2018) What Works? A Meta Analysis of Recent Active Labor Market Program Evaluations. Journal of the European Economic Association.
- [X-katz-2022] Katz, Roth, Hendra & Schaberg (2022) Why Do Sectoral Employment Programs Work? Lessons from WorkAdvance. Journal of Labor Economics.
- [X-hara-2022] Hara (2022) The effect of public-sponsored job training in Japan. Journal of the Japanese and International Economies.
- [X-hara-2022-mhlw] Hara (2022) An introduction to research on measuring the effects of public vocational training (in Japanese). Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare, study group on employment insurance.
Studies describe average tendencies. This article is not a promise that a habit will lift your income, and it is not medical or investment advice. About these articles ・ Search & sources
Updated:
← All articles