SALARYMAXReads

Deep dive ・ 7 min

Do money worries make it harder to think clearly?

A 2013 US and India study said money worries briefly lowered thinking. A US study of 3,821 people found no payday gap, and only 4 of 20 scarcity-study replications held up.

Do money worries make it harder to think clearly? — 4 of 20: Scarcity studies that held up when repeated (replications, randomised trials)

The evidence behind this article

  • Randomised trial3
  • Natural experiment1

Includes studies built to test cause and effect (randomised trials or natural experiments).

6 sources・Countries studied: United States, India, Singapore

How to read the kinds of evidence →

What to do with this

Write all your loan payments and direct debits on one page with their due dates. Having many separate debts may weigh on the mind, so start by making them visible.

Most people know how hard it is to focus when money is on their mind. A famous 2013 study reported that money worries themselves lower our ability to think. Later reanalyses and replications, meaning attempts to repeat a study with the same method, have not all agreed.

Key points

  • A 2013 study of shoppers at a US mall and sugarcane farmers in India reported that thinking about a costly financial problem lowered test scores only for people with lower incomes, and that farmers scored lower before harvest than after.
  • A reanalysis published the same year found the result was not supported when income was not split into two groups. A later US study that randomly surveyed 3,821 low-income adults before or after payday found no difference in thinking tests.
  • When 20 studies on the psychology of scarcity were repeated with 2.5 times as many participants, only 4 produced clear results. Yet in Singapore, people who had more debts cleared scored higher on thinking tests, so the debate continues.

What did the 2013 study show about money worries?

The first part of the study by Anandi Mani and colleagues was a set of experiments at a shopping mall in New Jersey. According to the university’s press release, about 400 people took part in 2010 and 2011. Participants imagined a car repair costing either $150 or $1,500 and then completed spatial and reasoning tasks. When the repair was cheap, lower-income people did fine. When it was expensive, their scores dropped. Higher-income people performed well in both cases.

The second part followed 464 sugarcane farmers in Tamil Nadu, India, who rely on the annual harvest for at least 60% of their income. The same farmers scored lower before harvest, when money was short, than after harvest. The authors wrote that differences in time, nutrition or work effort could not explain this.

Their interpretation was that money worries use up mental capacity, leaving less for other tasks. The university’s release compared the drop to roughly 13 IQ points, and the claim was widely reported.

Did reanalyses and replications find the same thing?

In December 2013 the same journal published a comment by Jelte Wicherts and Annemarie Zand Scholten. When they reanalysed the data without splitting income into “high” and “low”, the findings were not supported, and they argued that short, easy tests may have created a misleading pattern. They also suggested that money worries might affect people at all income levels. The original authors replied that their results held when income was treated as a continuous number.

In 2016 a US team tested the idea differently. They randomly assigned 3,821 adults with household incomes below $40,000 to take thinking tests either shortly before or shortly after payday. The two groups performed about the same. The before-payday group did, however, lean more towards “now” when choosing when to receive money.

In 2021 a group of researchers selected 20 studies on the psychology of scarcity, registered their methods in advance, and repeated each with 2.5 times the original sample. Only 4 produced statistically clear results, and in 80% of cases the effect was smaller than originally reported. The authors concluded that making people feel short of resources had minimal influence on thinking ability, though it might still affect money decisions.

Did thinking improve when debts were cleared?

A study in Singapore, published in 2019, used a charity programme that unexpectedly paid off debts of up to 5,000 Singapore dollars, about three months of household income, for low-income families. Comparing 196 people before and after, those who had one more debt account cleared, for the same total amount, scored higher on thinking tests. They were also 11% less likely to show anxiety and 10% less likely to choose “now” over “later”. The size of the payment itself showed no effect on anxiety or decisions. The researchers concluded that juggling several separate debts takes up mental bandwidth.

What can and cannot be said from this debate

A fair summary is that money worries have been reported to lower thinking ability, but many follow-up tests have not confirmed it.

  • Brief lab manipulations look weak. In the replications, simply making people feel short of money had minimal effect on thinking.
  • Real debt may be different. The Singapore study used a natural opportunity, but it involved 196 people in one country.
  • This is not about anyone’s ability. These studies asked whether a situation affects how the mind works. None of them says people short of money are less capable.
  • No Japanese study was found on this question.

A small step for today

The evidence is mixed, but one study suggests that having many separate debts may itself be a mental load.

  • List your loans and direct debits on one page with their due dates. You can do it alongside “Tracked spending”.
  • Use “Reviewed one fixed cost” to decide on just one item, with the aim of having one less thing to think about.
  • If you struggle to focus on some days, go easy on yourself. These studies were about the effect of circumstances, not about people.

FAQ

Do money worries stop your brain from working properly?

A 2013 study reported this, but later reanalyses and replications have not agreed. A US study of 3,821 people found no difference in thinking before and after payday, and only 4 of 20 scarcity-study replications held up. For now, the answer is not clear.

Has the idea that poverty lowers cognitive ability been disproved?

Not entirely. Short lab manipulations have looked weak in replications, but field studies like the original farmer study are hard to repeat. In Singapore, people who had more debt accounts cleared scored higher on thinking tests.

Does having debt lead to worse decisions?

In a Singapore study of 196 people, each extra debt account cleared made people 10% less likely to choose “now” over “later”. It is a small, single-country study and cannot predict any individual’s decisions.

Sources

  • [X-mani-2013] Mani, Mullainathan, Shafir & Zhao (2013) Poverty Impedes Cognitive Function. Science.
  • [X-wicherts-scholten-2013] Wicherts & Scholten (2013) Comment on “Poverty Impedes Cognitive Function”. Science.
  • [X-mani-2013-response] Mani, Mullainathan, Shafir & Zhao (2013) Response to Comment on “Poverty Impedes Cognitive Function”. Science.
  • [X-carvalho-meier-wang-2016] Carvalho, Meier & Wang (2016) Poverty and Economic Decision-Making: Evidence from Changes in Financial Resources at Payday. American Economic Review.
  • [X-odonnell-2021] O’Donnell et al. (2021) Empirical audit and review and an assessment of evidentiary value in research on the psychological consequences of scarcity. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
  • [X-ong-2019] Ong, Theseira & Ng (2019) Reducing debt improves psychological functioning and changes decision-making in the poor. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

Studies describe average tendencies. This article is not a promise that a habit will lift your income, and it is not medical or investment advice. About these articles ・ Search & sources

Updated:

← All articles