Basics ・ 6 min
Do Weak Ties Help You Change Jobs? A 20-Million-User Test
Randomized tests on over 20 million LinkedIn users found moderately weak ties led to the most job moves. They measured mobility, not pay; Japan data favored strong ties.

The evidence behind this article
- Randomised trial1
- Adjusted observational1
- Observational1
Includes studies built to test cause and effect (randomised trials or natural experiments).
3 sources・Countries studied: United States, Japan, Several countries
How to read the kinds of evidence →What to do with this
Put a time on your calendar to send a short note to a former colleague or old friend you haven't talked to in a while. Look after your close ties, too.
Do “weak ties,” such as acquaintances you only see now and then, help you change jobs? A large experiment on LinkedIn found that moderately weak ties created the most job moves. But it measured job applications and job changes, not whether anyone earned more.
Key points
- In experiments that randomly changed LinkedIn’s connection recommendations for more than 20 million users (in 2015 and 2019), weak ties increased job mobility. But the relationship was an inverted U: past a certain point, weaker ties added less.
- The effect of weak ties differed by industry. In more digital industries, weak ties led to more job applications; in less digital industries, strong ties did.
- A Japanese study of men who had changed jobs in the Tokyo area (Watanabe 1991) found that job changes made through strong ties tended to come with higher annual income and job satisfaction, and did not support the weak-ties hypothesis.
What did the 1973 “strength of weak ties” study in the US show?
In 1973, sociologist Mark Granovetter argued that close friends tend to share the same circle and therefore the same information. People you see only occasionally move in other circles, so they are more likely to bring you news you have not heard. He called this “the strength of weak ties.”
As an illustration, he surveyed recent job changers in professional, technical and managerial jobs living in a Boston suburb. Among the 54 people who found a job through a personal contact, 16.7% said they saw that contact often (at least twice a week) at the time, 55.6% occasionally, and 27.8% rarely (once a year or less). In many cases the contact was someone only loosely connected to them now, such as an old college friend or a former workmate or employer. It was a small survey, and it did not hold other factors constant.
Which LinkedIn ties led to the most job moves?
About 50 years later, Karthik Rajkumar and co-authors analyzed experiments on LinkedIn’s “People You May Know” feature, which varied what kinds of people it recommended. The 2015 experiment covered more than 4 million people (98.8% in the US), and the 2019 experiments covered more than 16 million people worldwide. Over five years, about 2 billion new connections and 600,000 new jobs were created.
They measured two things: how many jobs people applied to in the three months after an experiment, and whether someone later moved to a company where a connection worked (a “job transmission”).
A simple comparison made strong ties look more useful: people with more strong ties had more job moves. But when the researchers used only the differences created by the random experiments, the result reversed. Moderately weak ties, measured by the number of mutual connections, and the weakest ties, measured by how often people interacted, created the most job mobility. Weaker was not always better: beyond a certain point, the benefit got smaller.
By industry, weak ties led to more job applications in industries that rely heavily on IT and software or are well suited to remote work. Strong ties led to more applications in industries that rely less on software and robots.
How to read the research on weak ties and changing jobs
First, this is research on job mobility, not on income. The LinkedIn experiments did not measure whether people’s pay went up after they moved.
Second, consider who was studied. Users chose whether to accept recommendations, and those affected by the experiments were slightly younger and more active job seekers. LinkedIn users are concentrated in finance, information, professional services, high tech and construction.
In Japan, Watanabe (1991) surveyed men living in Tokyo, Kanagawa, Chiba and Saitama who had changed jobs. Even after accounting for their previous job and basic characteristics, strong ties gave them enough job information and were linked with higher annual income, stronger commitment to the company and higher job satisfaction. The author argues that strong ties play a strategic role in job changes in Japan. It is an older survey of men only, but it fits with the LinkedIn finding that strong ties led to more applications in less digital industries.
A small step for today
- Set a time to send a short note to a former colleague or an old friend you have not talked to for a while. Treat it like “Set when and where to do tomorrow’s key task” and put it on your calendar first.
- Keep up “Wrote one line on today’s progress.” When you reconnect with someone, you can explain what you are working on in a sentence or two.
- Look after your strong ties too. In the Japanese study, and in less digital industries, people close to you mattered more.
FAQ
Does having a wide network help you change jobs?
In the large LinkedIn experiments, people who gained more moderately weak ties had more job moves. But very weak ties added less, and in less digital industries strong ties led to more job applications.
Does changing jobs through weak ties lead to higher pay?
We don’t know. The LinkedIn experiments measured applications and job moves, not income. In the Japanese study (Watanabe 1991), job changes through strong ties were the ones linked with higher annual income.
What counts as a weak tie?
Granovetter measured it by how often people saw each other: “often” was at least twice a week and “rarely” was once a year or less. The LinkedIn study measured it in two ways: the number of mutual connections and how often two people interacted.
Sources
- [X-rajkumar-2022] Rajkumar, Saint-Jacques, Bojinov, Brynjolfsson & Aral (2022) A causal test of the strength of weak ties. Science.
- [X-granovetter-1973] Granovetter (1973) The Strength of Weak Ties. American Journal of Sociology.
- [X-watanabe-1991] Watanabe (1991) The effects of networks on job-change outcomes (in Japanese). Japanese Sociological Review.
Studies describe average tendencies. This article is not a promise that a habit will lift your income, and it is not medical or investment advice. About these articles ・ Search & sources
Updated:
← All articles