SALARYMAXReads

Basics ・ 6 min

Do you spend more with a card than with cash?

In a US ticket auction, students told to pay by card bid $61 on average, over twice the $29 bid by those paying cash. A meta-analysis of 71 papers finds a smaller effect.

Do you spend more with a card than with cash? — Small effect: Extra spending when paying without cash (71 papers, meta-analysis)

The evidence behind this article

  • Randomised trial1
  • Natural experiment1
  • Research synthesis1

Includes studies built to test cause and effect (randomised trials or natural experiments).

3 sources・Countries studied: United States, Japan, Several countries

How to read the kinds of evidence →

What to do with this

Log card and phone payments the same day, and for purchases others will see, such as clothes, try waiting a night before you buy.

It can feel easier to spend when you tap a card or a phone. In a well-known US experiment, people told they would pay by credit card bid more than twice as much as people told they would pay in cash. When later research is pooled, though, the effect is real but small, and its size varies from one situation to another.

Key points

  • In an experiment with master’s students at MIT in the US (published in 2001), people bid for tickets to a professional basketball game. Those told they would pay by credit card bid $61 on average, more than twice the $29 bid by those told they would pay in cash.
  • A 2024 meta-analysis, a method that combines many studies, pooled 392 results from 71 papers. It found that paying without cash raises spending by a small but statistically significant amount, and that the effect has weakened over time.
  • A working paper from Japan, not yet peer reviewed, used account data from a major bank. When campaigns raised QR code payments, other spending rose by about the same amount, but the effect was short-lived.

How much more would people pay for tickets by card than by cash?

Drazen Prelec and Duncan Simester asked master’s students at MIT’s business school to bid for a pair of tickets to a Boston Celtics game. Bids were sealed, and the highest bidder bought the tickets at the second-highest price. In this format, the best strategy is to write down the most you are truly willing to pay.

Half the participants received a bidding sheet saying payment would be in cash within 24 hours. The other half received a sheet saying payment would be by credit card. Participants did not know that a different set of instructions existed.

The average bid was $29 in the cash group and $61 in the card group. Among the top 20% of bids, the average was $53 for cash and $142 for card. The tickets were the same; only the payment method in the instructions changed, yet the amount people were willing to pay shifted a lot.

A second prize, dinner for four, gave mixed results. When people were asked to write part of their card number to identify themselves, card bids were 36% higher. Without that step, card bids were 13% lower, and the difference was not statistically significant. These figures come from teaching material the authors used at MIT.

What did later research find about the cashless effect?

Research linking non-cash payment to higher spending goes back more than 40 years. Some studies, however, question how reliable the effect is.

The 2024 meta-analysis gathered 392 results from 71 papers. Paying without cash raised spending by a small but statistically significant amount. The type of payment method, such as card or phone, made no clear difference. The situation did matter. The effect was stronger for purchases meant to be seen by others and weaker for spending on others, such as giving. It was stronger in periods of economic growth, and it has generally weakened over time.

In Japan, Hinata Sasaki and Kozo Ueda wrote a working paper using account data from a major bank. From July 2020 to February 2021, local governments worked with a QR code payment company on campaigns that gave back 20–30% of the amount paid. The authors used the timing and location of these campaigns, which users could not choose, to study spending. When QR code payments rose, other spending rose by about the same amount. The effect was transitory, however.

How to read research on payment methods and spending

  • The first study is an experiment that changed only the payment instructions. That makes it reasonable to say the payment method itself changed the bids. Still, it is a small group of business school students in a 2001 paper. A doubling is much larger than the average effect in the meta-analysis.
  • The size of the effect varies. In the meta-analysis it was small on average and changed with the situation and the period. People becoming more used to non-cash payment is one possible reason the effect has weakened.
  • The Japanese working paper has not been peer reviewed. Its data come from a rebate campaign period, and it measures payments as transfers from bank accounts into QR payment accounts. It may not apply directly to everyday payments. It is the only Japanese study we were able to verify for this article.

A small step for today

  • Log non-cash payments the same day with “Tracked spending”. The record makes up for the weaker sense of paying.
  • For purchases that others will see, such as clothes or gadgets, try “Waited a night before buying”. That is where the meta-analysis found a stronger effect.
  • Rather than worrying about whether to go back to cash, focus on whether you can see what you spent.

FAQ

Do you overspend when you pay by card?

On average, people tend to spend a little more. A meta-analysis of 71 papers found that paying without cash raises spending by a small but statistically significant amount. The size varies by situation, and it has weakened over time.

Is it the same with QR code payments on a phone?

A Japanese working paper using major bank account data found that when campaigns raised QR code payments, other spending rose by about the same amount, but only for a short time. The paper has not been peer reviewed, and its data come from a rebate campaign period, so it may not apply directly to everyday payments.

Is it true that people pay twice as much with a card?

A 2001 US experiment found a result like that, but the effect is not always that large. In that study, MIT students bidding for basketball tickets offered $29 on average in cash and $61 by card. Pooling 71 later papers, the effect was smaller.

Sources

  • [X-prelec-simester-2001] Prelec & Simester (2001) Always Leave Home Without It: A Further Investigation of the Credit-Card Effect on Willingness to Pay. Marketing Letters.
  • [X-schomburgk-belli-hoffmann-2024] Schomburgk, Belli & Hoffmann (2024) Less cash, more splash? A meta-analysis on the cashless effect. Journal of Retailing.
  • [X-sasaki-ueda-2024] Sasaki & Ueda (2024) Do Cashless Payments Stimulate Spending? Evidence from QR Code Payment Campaigns and Bank Transaction Data in Japan. CIGS Working Paper.

Studies describe average tendencies. This article is not a promise that a habit will lift your income, and it is not medical or investment advice. About these articles ・ Search & sources

Updated:

← All articles