SALARYMAXReads

Basics ・ 6 min

Does your college major change your earnings? A Norway study

A natural experiment at Norway's admission cutoffs found similar applicants earned very different sums by field. A working paper put science at about 3 times humanities.

Does your college major change your earnings? A Norway study — Major matters: Pay differed more by field than by college attended (Norway, natural experiment)

The evidence behind this article

  • Natural experiment1
  • Adjusted observational1

Includes studies built to test cause and effect (randomised trials or natural experiments).

2 sources・Countries studied: Norway, Japan

How to read the kinds of evidence →

What to do with this

When you choose a major or a field to retrain in, look beyond average pay: write down whether it suits your strengths and how it differs from your next choice.

How much does your university major change what you earn? A study using Norway’s admission system found that applicants with similar grades, split by the admission cutoff, earned very different amounts early in their careers depending on their field. But the size of the gap depended on which fields were being compared, and choosing a field that suits you also mattered.

Key points

  • A natural experiment using admission cutoffs for Norwegian university applications from 1998 to 2004 (Kirkeboen, Leuven and Mogstad, 2016) found large differences in earnings between fields, even after accounting for the institution and the quality of fellow students. Differences between institutions were smaller than differences between fields.
  • In the working paper version of the same study, comparing earnings 8 years after applying, people who chose science (such as mathematics, physics and computer science) instead of the humanities earned about 3 times as much (almost triple). Choosing science instead of engineering or business made little difference.
  • A Japanese study using the 2005 national SSM survey found that among women with university degrees, those who studied science or engineering earned less than those who studied the humanities or social sciences, with the gap especially large when they did not work in professional jobs (observational study).

How did earnings differ for Norwegian applicants split by the admission cutoff?

In Norway, a national body runs admissions for almost all universities and colleges. Applicants rank up to 15 combinations of institution and field, such as teaching at the University of Oslo, and places are given out in order of a score based on high school grades.

The minimum score for admission changes across institutions and years, and applicants cannot predict it. So people who just cleared the cutoff for their first choice and people who just missed it and went to their second choice have almost the same grades. Which field they enter is close to being decided by lottery, so they can be compared as a natural experiment.

The researchers linked application records from 1998 to 2004 to tax records and looked at earnings 8 years after the application. The working paper version analyses about 50,000 people.

Earnings differed a great deal by field, and for many fields the difference rivalled the gap between going to university and not going. For example, people who chose science instead of the humanities (such as history, philosophy and languages) earned almost three times as much early in their careers. Choosing science instead of engineering or business, however, brought little extra.

Did the field matter more than the university?

The study also looked at which institution people attended. The earnings effect of getting into a more selective institution was relatively small compared with the effect of the field.

Another key finding is that people tended to choose fields in which they had a comparative advantage, meaning fields they were better at relative to others. In the working paper version, most people earned more in their first-choice field than they would have in their next-best field. The same field can pay off differently for people who suit it and people who do not.

What does research show about majors and earnings in Japan?

In Japan, a study by Yamamoto and Yasui (2016) used the 2005 national Social Stratification and Social Mobility survey (SSM). Looking at women with university degrees and accounting for occupation and type of employment, it found that those who studied science or engineering earned less than those who studied the humanities or social sciences. The gap was especially large in non-professional jobs; in professional jobs it shrank, but a small gap remained.

The authors argue that gender gaps in employment, combined with the male-dominated nature of science and engineering, leave many women unable to get professional jobs that match what they studied. How a major turns into earnings seems to depend on how workplaces are organised too.

How to read the research on majors and earnings

The Norwegian study is a natural experiment based on admission cutoffs, so it comes close to showing cause and effect. But it tells us about people near the cutoffs and about earnings early in their careers. It also reflects Norway’s system, where university is generally free of tuition fees, and Norway’s labour market. The figure of almost three times for science comes from the working paper version.

The Japanese study is observational and covers women who graduated from university, surveyed in 2005. We did not find a Japanese study that uses admission cutoffs to estimate the effect of a major.

What this evidence supports is that in Norway, people with similar grades earned very different amounts early in their careers depending on the field they entered, and the gap depended on the alternative field and on whether the field suited the person. It does not mean that everyone gains the same amount by choosing a higher-paying field.

A small step for today

  • Use “Studied for 30 minutes” to try one introductory book or course in a field you are considering. It helps you see whether you are good at it and could keep going.
  • Use “Wrote one line on today’s progress” to note which kinds of tasks went smoothly. Over time, you will see which fields suit you.
  • When you compare fields, look beyond average pay and write down how each one differs from your next-best option.

FAQ

Do science majors earn more?

It depends on the comparison. In the working paper version of the Norwegian study, people who chose science instead of the humanities earned almost three times as much early in their careers, but there was little difference compared with engineering or business. A 2005 Japanese survey even found that women who studied science or engineering earned less than those who studied the humanities or social sciences.

Which matters more for earnings, the major or the university?

In the Norwegian study, the earnings effect of getting into a more selective institution was relatively small compared with the effect of the field. Large differences between fields remained even after accounting for the institution and the quality of fellow students.

Does everyone gain by choosing a higher-paying field?

Not necessarily. In the Norwegian study, people tended to choose fields they were relatively good at, and most earned more in their first-choice field than they would have in their next-best one. What you gain depends on how well a field suits you.

Sources

  • [X-kirkeboen-2016] Kirkeboen, Leuven & Mogstad (2016) Field of Study, Earnings, and Self-Selection. The Quarterly Journal of Economics.
  • [X-yamamoto-yasui-2016] 山本・安井 (2016) 大卒女性における専攻間賃金格差の分析――理工系出身女性の賃金抑制要因に注目して――. ソシオロジ.

Studies describe average tendencies. This article is not a promise that a habit will lift your income, and it is not medical or investment advice. About these articles ・ Search & sources

Updated:

← All articles