Practice ・ 7 min
Does financial education change how people handle money?
A 2022 meta-analysis of 76 randomised trials in 33 countries found financial education improved knowledge and saving. A 2014 review saw tiny effects from just 13 trials.

The evidence behind this article
- Research synthesis2
- Official guideline1
Includes an analysis that pools many studies, which is less swayed by chance in any single one.
3 sources・Countries studied: Japan, Several countries
How to read the kinds of evidence →What to do with this
In the week before you decide on a loan, insurance or a savings plan, spend 30 minutes learning only about that decision, so you can use it while it is fresh.
Does a money course actually change what people do? A large 2014 analysis found tiny effects that quickly faded. A 2022 analysis found that financial education improves both knowledge and behaviour. The difference comes mainly from how many studies were available and which kinds were included.
Key points
- A 2014 meta-analysis, which pools many studies to estimate an average, combined 201 studies and found that financial education explained only 0.1% of the differences in financial behaviour, with almost no effect 20 months or more later.
- A 2022 meta-analysis of 76 randomised trials (where chance decides who gets the course) in 33 countries, with more than 160,000 people, found that financial education improved knowledge and behaviours such as saving. The effect was about 5.5 times the 2014 estimate for trials.
- In 2014 only 13 randomised trials were available. In Japan, only 7.1% of adults said in 2022 that they had received financial education, and no Japanese randomised trial was found.
How did the 2014 analysis judge financial education?
In 2014, Daniel Fernandes, John Lynch and Richard Netemeyer combined 201 studies from 168 papers, including both randomised trials and studies based on everyday survey data.
Their conclusions were stark:
- Financial education explained just 0.1% of the differences in the financial behaviours studied.
- Effects were weaker in studies of people on low incomes.
- Like other education, the effect faded over time. Even long programmes with many hours of teaching had negligible effects on behaviour 20 months or more later.
Correlational studies, which compare people who know more about money with those who know less, showed much stronger links. But when the authors controlled for psychological traits in their own data, those links shrank dramatically. Part of what looked like the effect of knowledge may have been personality.
The authors argued for a smaller role for financial education, but saw value in “just-in-time” teaching focused on a specific decision, shortly before people make it, such as taking out a loan.
Why did the 2022 analysis reach a different conclusion?
In 2022, Tim Kaiser, Annamaria Lusardi, Lukas Menkhoff and Carly Urban repeated the exercise using only randomised trials. Because chance decides who takes part, these trials help rule out the idea that keen people simply sign up.
The 2014 analysis had 13 randomised trials. By 2019 there were 76. Combining those trials from 33 countries and more than 160,000 people, they found:
- Financial education improved financial knowledge and behaviours such as borrowing, saving, budgeting and insurance.
- Effects on knowledge were similar to maths and reading programmes; effects on behaviour were similar to health behaviour-change programmes.
- The effect on behaviour was about 0.1 standard deviations, a common way of measuring effect size. That is about 5.5 times the 2014 estimate for randomised trials (0.018).
- There was no difference in effect between people on low incomes and everyone else.
- Effects shrank somewhat when measured six months or more later, but did not keep falling after that. Even in the seven trials measured two years or more later, the effect was not zero.
Programmes averaged about 12 hours of teaching, and effects were measured about seven months later.
How many people in Japan have had financial education?
In 2022 Japan’s Central Council for Financial Services Information surveyed 30,000 people aged 18 to 79 online. Only 7.1% said they had received financial education at school or work, little changed from 6.6% in 2016 and 7.2% in 2019. In a comparable US survey the figure was 20%.
In the Japanese survey, people who had received financial education scored higher on knowledge questions and were more likely to compare products when investing or borrowing. This compares two groups, so it cannot show that the education caused the difference. 71.8% said schools should teach it.
How to read the two conclusions
A fair reading is that financial education, on average, improves knowledge and behaviour a little, and the effect fades somewhat over time.
- This is less a contradiction than a difference in timing and method. In 2014 there were few trials, and correlational studies were included. By 2022 there were many more trials, and only those were used.
- An effect of about 0.1 is modest. It is an average tendency, not a large change for any one person.
- No Japanese randomised trial was found. We do not know whether schools or workplaces in Japan would see the same results.
- Both analyses suggest effects can fade. The 2014 idea of learning just before a decision is still a useful one.
A small step for today
The research supports a simple rule: learn close to when you will use it, and focus on that topic.
- If you plan to decide on a loan, insurance or a savings plan, use “Studied for 30 minutes” in the week before, on that single topic.
- Put what you learned into practice the same week. For example, review the settings behind “Paid myself first”.
- Use “Tracked spending” to see where your money goes, so it is clearer what you need to learn.
FAQ
Does financial education change how people manage money?
A 2022 analysis of 76 randomised trials in 33 countries found that, on average, financial education improved behaviours such as saving. The effect was modest, about 0.1 standard deviations, not a large change for any one person.
Why do some studies say financial education does not work?
A 2014 analysis of 201 studies found that financial education explained only 0.1% of the differences in financial behaviour. At the time, though, there were only 13 randomised trials. The 2022 analysis, with 76 trials, estimated an effect about 5.5 times larger.
How long does the effect of financial education last?
In the 2022 analysis, effects shrank somewhat after six months but did not keep falling; even seven trials measured two or more years later did not show zero. The 2014 analysis found almost no effect after 20 months.
Sources
- [X-fernandes-2014] Fernandes, Lynch & Netemeyer (2014) Financial Literacy, Financial Education, and Downstream Financial Behaviors. Management Science.
- [D5] Kaiser, Lusardi, Menkhoff & Urban (2022) Financial education affects financial knowledge and downstream behaviors. Journal of Financial Economics.
- [D4] Central Council for Financial Services Information (2022) Financial Literacy Survey 2022.
Studies describe average tendencies. This article is not a promise that a habit will lift your income, and it is not medical or investment advice. About these articles ・ Search & sources
Updated:
← All articles