SALARYMAXReads

Basics ・ 6 min

Does spending money on others make you happier?

In the original team's large preregistered replications, buying a gift for someone raised happiness, while merely recalling past spending showed no or small gaps.

Does spending money on others make you happier? — $2.50: Sum that lifted mood more when spent on others (Canada, randomised trial)

The evidence behind this article

  • Randomised trial2
  • Observational1

Includes studies built to test cause and effect (randomised trials or natural experiments).

3 sources・Countries studied: United States, Canada, Several countries

How to read the kinds of evidence →

What to do with this

Next time you shop, pick up one small thing for someone close to you, then jot down one line about how you felt to see whether it suits you.

Does spending on other people make you happier too? A well-known 2008 study said yes, and the same research team later checked the idea again with much larger samples. When people actually bought something for someone else, happiness went up; when they only recalled past spending, the difference was absent or small.

Key points

  • In a 2008 national survey of 632 Americans, people who spent more on gifts for others and on charity tended to be happier, while spending on themselves was unrelated to happiness (a correlation).
  • In the same paper, 46 participants were given $5 or $20 and randomly told how to spend it. Those who spent it on others were happier that evening, and the amount made no difference.
  • In a 2020 preregistered replication by the same team, the effect held in an experiment with 712 Canadian students. A recall experiment with 1,950 US adults found no difference, and an improved version with 5,199 people found only a small one.

The original study: money spent on others and happiness

In 2008, Elizabeth Dunn, Lara Aknin and Michael Norton reported three studies in the journal Science.

The first was a nationally representative survey of 632 Americans. It split monthly spending into “for yourself” (bills, expenses and gifts for yourself) and “for others” (gifts for others and charity). Spending on yourself was unrelated to happiness, but people who spent more on others tended to be happier. This link was separate from income and about as strong. People also spent more than ten times as much on themselves as on others.

The second followed 16 employees who received a profit-sharing bonus averaging about $4,900. The larger the share of the bonus they spent on others, the happier they tended to be six to eight weeks later, even after accounting for how happy they were before.

The third was an experiment. After rating their happiness in the morning, 46 participants received an envelope with $5 or $20 to spend by 5 p.m. A random draw decided whether they spent it on themselves or on a gift for someone else or a donation. That evening, those who spent on others were happier, and the amount did not matter. When 109 other students were asked to predict the results, most expected spending on themselves, and getting $20, to make them happier.

In 2013, a team that included the same researchers examined survey data from 136 countries and reported that people who spent money on others tended to be happier in poor and rich countries alike.

How far did the preregistered replication confirm it?

The 2008 experiment was small, and most prosocial spending studies used fewer than 100 people per condition. In light of stricter standards of evidence, Aknin and the same team ran large replications in 2020, registering their methods before seeing the data.

  • Experiment 1 (712 students at two Canadian universities): Participants received $2.50 and were randomly assigned to buy a bag of treats for themselves or for a sick child in hospital. Those who bought for the child reported more positive mood in the moment, as predicted.
  • Experiment 2 (1,950 US adults, online): People recalled a time they spent money on themselves or on someone else. Their current happiness did not differ.
  • Experiment 3 (5,199 adults, online): With small changes to make people engage more with the recall task, those who recalled spending on others were happier, but the difference was small.

The authors conclude that spending money on others does promote happiness, but that the size of the effect depends on how it is studied.

How to read research on spending on others

  • Cause and effect comes from the randomized experiments. The national survey and the bonus study are correlations; happier people may simply be more likely to spend on others.
  • The replication was done by the original team. It was preregistered and large, but it was not an independent replication by another group.
  • Mostly, momentary mood was measured. The recall experiments looked back on past spending; they did not follow the same people over a long time.
  • The effect depends on the method. It showed clearly when people actually bought and gave something, and was absent or small when they only remembered.
  • We did not find a Japanese study. We also could not confirm whether Japan was among the 136 countries in the 2013 study.

A small step for today

The effects in these studies came from small amounts, a few dollars, actually spent on someone else. That is easy to try.

  • When you use “Tracked spending,” mark what you spent on other people and see the weekly total.
  • Before a big impulse purchase, use “Waited a night before buying” to think about who you really want to give to, and how much.
  • Next time you shop, pick up one small thing for someone close to you. Jot down one line about how you felt afterwards to see whether it suits you.

FAQ

Does spending money on others make you happier?

In experiments that randomly assigned how people spent money, those who spent on others were happier that day. In the large 2020 replication, the same result appeared when people actually bought and gave something. When people only recalled past spending, the difference was absent or small, so the size of the effect depended on the method.

Is it better to give a larger amount?

In the 2008 experiment, spending $5 or $20 on others made no difference to how much happier people became. With only 46 participants, though, the study cannot rule out any effect of the amount.

Has this research been replicated?

Partly. In the 2020 preregistered replication, the effect held with 712 Canadian students, but there was no difference with 1,950 US adults, and only a small one in an improved study of 5,199 people. The replication was carried out by the original team.

Sources

  • [X-dunn-aknin-norton-2008] Dunn, Aknin & Norton (2008) Spending Money on Others Promotes Happiness. Science.
  • [X-aknin-2013] Aknin et al. (2013) Prosocial spending and well-being: Cross-cultural evidence for a psychological universal. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.
  • [X-aknin-2020] Aknin, Dunn, Proulx, Lok & Norton (2020) Does spending money on others promote happiness?: A registered replication report. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.

Studies describe average tendencies. This article is not a promise that a habit will lift your income, and it is not medical or investment advice. About these articles ・ Search & sources

Updated:

← All articles